While a panel of judges has ruled the Central East Local Health Integration Network (CE LHIN) acted lawfully in not consulting the public before approving changes to the Ajax-Pickering hospital, as a public institution it, and especially the hospital board, should have done so.
The changes included the controversial movement of 20 mental health beds from the Ajax-Pickering to the Centenary hospital, which together make up the Rouge Valley Health System (RVHS). The Ontario Public Service Employees Union (OPSEU) took the CE LHIN to court over the matter, and the panel of three judges of the Divisional Court of the Ontario Supreme Court of Justice dismissed OPSEU's application for a judicial review.
"The LHIN did not require approval of the specific measures proposed by RVHS, as that was an internal hospital decision," the ruling stated. "What (the) LHIN decided was to fund RVHS on the basis of its representations in the respect of fiscal improvements aimed at eliminating the budget deficit."
The last line is interesting in basically stating the decision was made to save money. Was it then just a happy coincidence that the removal of the mental health beds from Ajax to Scarborough would also mean better service for the patients and residents of Ajax-Pickering, as former hospital board chairman Tom Atkins and Rik Ganderton, Rouge Valley president and CEO, stated after the public furor? Was it one, the other or both?
The first line, it could easily be argued, confirms suspicions that the LHINs were created as a buffer to further distance the public from the provincial ministry of health and local health-care decision-making.
Regardless, the issue is that the general public was kept out of the loop and there was no public consultation whatsoever until media pressure forced it.
The hospital board had the opportunity, well before the decision was put in place and approved, to explain to the community what was happening, when and why. When this occurs after the fact, the average citizen is rightly suspicious, even angry, as occurred in this case.
As we said in a previous editorial, consultation does not necessarily mean the public will determine what occurs at the hospital and, specifically in this case, how the budget deficit should be addressed. Joe and Jane public are simply not qualified to offer that kind of input.
However consultation would have allowed Mr. Ganderton to make the case for the beds move before the media coverage of the public's outrage. He did this as damage control in a letter to the editor, stating that "lost is the fact the new model (for mental health care) will improve mental health care by" etc.
It was his and the board's job to ensure this message was not lost, even if members of the public didn't believe him.
Recommend :
More Editorials
Deficit-free plan offers real leadership for CanadiansCome rain, come sleet, come hail or recession, no deficit shall we run, says our finance minister. That was the message presented by Jim Flaherty in the House of Commons ...
Reaching out to Ajacians a laudable goalAjax Council is making out-reach to its citizens a more important part of its strategic plan, a move we heartily endorse. It's hard to believe that half of the current ...
Region sets clear direction for recyclingThe Region of Durham wants to have a clear look at what residents are, or are not, sending to landfill disposal. A pilot project will take place in about 750 households in ...
Oshawa EI numbers frighteningMerry Christmas. Statistics Canada has confirmed what we already knew: staggering amounts of people in Oshawa are unemployed. Only StatsCan has shown us the numbers and ...
Don't drink and driveThe annual Festive RIDE (Reduce Impaired Driving Everywhere) campaign is on and one week in, the numbers are not encouraging. Twelve people were charged with drunk driving by ...
Now is no time to spend money buying buildingsLast week much discussion took place at Clarington council regarding the Total Hockey experiment that was put in place by the previous municipal council. As many may recall, ...
Need a doctor? Fourteen physicians are looking for patientsAt first blush, the statement seems paradoxical -- Oshawa is short at least 28 physicians but there are 14 doctors looking for new patients. The question comes to mind, if ...
Pickering, Ajax councillors right to question Metrolinx planAjax and Pickering councils have some legitimate concerns about the 25-year Metrolinx plan, concerns that must be taken into account and addressed. Released recently by ...
Give as generously as you can this Christmas seasonAmid all the grim news about layoffs and tough times in our economic outlook comes the realization that for some, this will be a truly difficult Christmas. Those among us who ...
Tough laws meant to keep young drivers saferA tough new bill just introduced in the Ontario legislature has the express goal of making it safer out there for our young drivers. It follows up on the graduated licensing ...